Chris Bowers

Writer and Broadcaster

  • Home

  • About Chris

  • Environment

  • Tennis

  • Politics

  • Blog

  • Contact

  • More...

    There are now three halves in British politics

    September 22, 2019

    Talk of a coup in Britain is not exaggerated

    September 4, 2019

    They are demonstrating in my name

    April 23, 2019

    The democratic case for resolving Brexit

    April 17, 2019

    Raw eye-witness testimony of being a child in a competitive environment

    March 24, 2019

    The Stephen Lloyd case shows there is no room for nuance in politics

    December 8, 2018

    I’m now not so sure history will treat Nick Clegg kindly

    October 21, 2018

    If we want to solve problems, we have to listen to those we disagree with

    October 3, 2018

    Serena Williams owes at least two people an apology!

    September 8, 2018

    Is this the start of a brand new form of party politics?

    May 4, 2018

    Please reload

    Recent Posts

    A basic principle of justice

    July 24, 2016

    1/1
    Please reload

    Featured Posts

    Spare me ‘Sir Andy’

    December 31, 2016

     

    Honours lists are a minefield. Every country has them in some shape or form, and who gets honoured is a matter of great subjectivity. But leaving aside the rights and wrongs of who gets what, the British are relatively rare in that they give certain honours that change the courtesy title of the person who has been honoured: ‘Sir’, ‘Dame’, ‘Lord’, etc. And that’s where good journalists need to distinguish between admiration and sycophancy. Too often, they don’t.

     

    I have many misgivings about the British honours system, but there’s no question Andy Murray deserves the knighthood he has been given. He is arguably the UK’s greatest athlete. The only person who could come remotely close to challenging that at present is Mo Farah, and at least the fact that both men have received knighthoods in the New Year honours list corrects the uncomfortable omission of Farah from the top three in the BBC Sports Personality of the Year public poll.

     

    So from tomorrow (1 Jan), Murray will be referred to as ‘Sir Andy’, and Farah as ‘Sir Mo’. But these are courtesy titles, they are not changes of name. And the difference is important.

     

    Around the world, if someone completes a PhD, they are allowed to use the title ‘Dr’, but only in a few countries is it part of the name – elsewhere it is just a courtesy title. Germany is one of the countries where the name actually changes. If I were German and completed my PhD, I’d go to the local registry office to change my surname from ‘Bowers’ to ‘Dr Bowers’. Thereafter, anyone addressing me formally in German would call me ‘Herr Dr Bowers’. And if I write two theses and gain two PhDs, I’m ‘Herr Dr Dr Bowers’. (The reason for the name change is linked to how Germany has dealt with the remnants of its aristocracy, which doesn’t officially exist even if certain titles – like ‘von’, ‘Graf’, etc – still do, but that’s another story.)

     

    The British knighthood titles of ‘Sir’ and ‘Dame’ are courtesy titles. What that means is that if you used to call the world’s top tennis player ‘Mr Murray’, you should now call him ‘Sir Andy’. But in sport we very seldom use the titles ‘Mr’ or ‘Ms’. Therefore, Murray should remain just that: ‘Murray’ or ‘Andy Murray’.

     

    But it won’t happen like that, at least not in the UK. When the England football team won the world cup in 1966, its coach Alf Ramsey was knighted. Thereafter, he was ‘Sir Alf’. When Manchester United won the European Champions League in 1999, its coach Alex Ferguson was knighted. As a Liverpool supporter, I found that galling because Bob Paisley was never knighted despite winning three European titles for Liverpool two decades earlier (that too is another story, linked with Ferguson having supported the then governing Labour Party). More galling was the way journalists who had previously called Ferguson ‘Alex’ started referring to him as ‘Sir Alex’, a custom Ferguson appeared rather to enjoy.

     

    I feel that custom indicated a deference that became a sycophancy, which in turn prevented the scrutiny that good journalists should have exercised over Ferguson the coach. I don’t want journalists to be too chummy with athletes and coaches, but nor should they tug their forelock to them. At least Ferguson was a coach – in recent years we’ve had the childish situation of commentators having to talk about active sportsmen and women as ‘Sir Chris Hoy’, ‘Sir Bradley Wiggins’, ‘Dame Kelly Holmes’ etc. Are Rod Laver, Jack Nicklaus or Muhammad Ali any less of a legend because they don’t have a courtesy title before their name? Of course not!

     

    As a commentator, I will continue to refer to the world’s top tennis player as ‘Andy Murray’ and ‘Murray’. I will not studiously avoid ‘Sir Andy’ because there may be moments when it adds gravitas to both his achievements and my commentary. But his name will not change, nor should it as the ‘Sir’ is just a courtesy title. And I offer this consolation to my non-British sporting colleagues: if you think the British honours business is all a bit silly in the 21st century, you’re not alone.

     

    Please reload

    Follow Us

    Anti Doping

    Athletics

    Caroline Lucas

    Chris Bowers

    IOC

    Politics

    Progressive Politics

    Wada

    ethics

    lisa Nandy

    Please reload

    Search By Tags

    September 2019 (2)

    April 2019 (2)

    March 2019 (1)

    December 2018 (1)

    October 2018 (2)

    September 2018 (1)

    May 2018 (1)

    April 2018 (1)

    February 2018 (1)

    October 2017 (1)

    September 2017 (1)

    August 2017 (1)

    May 2017 (1)

    April 2017 (1)

    March 2017 (1)

    February 2017 (1)

    January 2017 (1)

    December 2016 (2)

    November 2016 (1)

    October 2016 (2)

    September 2016 (4)

    August 2016 (3)

    July 2016 (2)

    Please reload

    Archive
    • Facebook Basic Square
    • Twitter Basic Square
    • Google+ Basic Square

    Header photograph John Robert Young (c) 2016

    Chris Bowers (c)  2019